HELP!! I am back to working on
Disconnect from the
Relationship Cycle... as you may recall it was a bust (see bottom image of this post). The colors were terrible & I was really unhappy with it. Well, I'm at the point where I need input on the image. I've redrawn the female figure & am happier with her at this point. I intentionally used myself as a model this time....even though I feel the woman's role in the work is universal, since the portfolio deals with my identity I want the work tied more to me. I've also played with the light. I want more darkness on the figures so that the beckoning light from the background is more prominent. I need real help with selecting the male for the new image. The first rough sketch shows the two male options and below are slightly more refined drawings of the female figure with the male in place.

This first sketch below has the male getting up & I really like the dynamics of the composition that it creates. The diagonals & additional focal point of the hand & fabric add to the image (I think) but the actual pose is changing the meaning of the work for me too much. Here the male is physically leaving... getting out of the union (bed, marriage, etc.) which is too strong of a break. For me, the meaning behind Disconnect is more emotional detachment and thus a part of a cycle that repeats in the relationship. If the male is physically leaving then the cycle is broken...

The image below is closer to my meaning & is much closer to the original composition but I don't think it is as dynamic because it lacks diagonals & the additional focal point to strengthen the composition. What I do like about it is that both figure are lost in their own thoughts, it is quiet & still. There will be some space above his head & the rectangular "window" will be on the right. Sorry for the mess with the tracing paper taped to the other drawing! What do you guys think? Which is stronger?

Below is the ugly original! Pink, what was I thinking?!